Good Girls in Trouble
Not only were women shielded from learning the very basics of human reproduction — knowledge which could have prevented many pregnancies — but they were also by default seen as unfit to care for their own children. Their choices were limited and of those few choices, each carried its own set of inherent dangers.
If a woman “in trouble” did choose to carry to term, and did not go to great lengths to hide her condition, she was at risk of a far worse fate than ostracism or poverty. Violence against pregnant women and infants was rampant. In many cases, the perpetrator was either the father of the baby, a family member, or both.
Pastor Murders Housemaid
In 1938, an Evangelical Lutheran pastor in North Dakota, Heio Janssen, murdered his 16-year-old housemaid, Alma Kruckenberg, simply because she was pregnant. He then burned down his home in an attempt to hide her body. When questioned, Janssen stated impassively:
The devil overcame me. I did wrong. I have a very good Christian wife and two boys any father would be proud of and I feel only too sorry that I bring such grief to them.1“
Shortly after his arrest, the pastor was convicted. Janssen admitted he was the father of the unborn child and he had killed Miss Kruckenberg to prevent his family from finding out2.
Sadly, Janssen’s case was not an isolated occurrence. That same year, 16-year-old Donald Carroll of New York was convicted of murdering his 18-year-old girlfriend when he learned she was pregnant. Carroll testified the death was part of a failed suicide pact. He claimed they had both chosen to end their lives because “death was the only way out.3”
This violence wasn’t limited to the mothers. In 1923, Mr. A. Vlemminck of Michigan kidnapped a newborn baby boy from the hospital, believing it belonged to his daughter. Thinking it was the product of his own incestuous act, he killed the infant and disposed of its body in the Detroit River. Twelve years later, it was revealed that he had stolen the wrong baby and had murdered another couple’s child.
At his trial, Vlemminck stated,”I’m sorry I killed your baby. I never would have done it if I had known it was not my child.4”
Young Father Drowns Newborn
In 1936, after a 17-year-old Minneapolis man’s girlfriend gave birth to their child, he stole the baby from the hospital and drowned it in a nearby river.5
Cases like these appear over and over in simple keyword searches of news archives. Though the murder of mothers and babies was far too common, it wasn’t only men who committed such unthinkable acts. Feeling trapped in unwanted pregnancies, some women took drastic measures.
Actress Commits Suicide
In 1944, actress and singer Lupe Vélez committed suicide by overdosing on the barbiturate Secanol. She was unmarried and pregnant and left a note, addressed to the father of her unborn child, actor Harald Ramond6:
To Harald, May God forgive you and forgive me too, but I prefer to take my life away and our baby’s before I bring him with shame or killing him. – Lupe.
Shame and sin are recurring themes in these tragic tales.
In 1943, a 23-year-old Denver woman, Bernice Williams was found with the remains of three newborn babies hidden in a hope chest. She had given birth to each child in secret and each time had attended to her own delivery and aftercare.
Bernice was an employed professional, working as a buyer for a department store at the time of her arrest. When questioned about the murders, she said she had to kill them because “they were children of sin.7”
In 1936, a 25-year-old Milwaukee woman left the body of her stillborn baby at a garbage dump. She was charged with failing to report the death of her child. When taken into custody, the unnamed woman appeared ill. Midwives and hospitals were not in short supply, so it can be assumed this woman had delivered her baby in secret and hoped to hide the evidence8.
Unwed Mother Tried as Baby-Slayer
Later that same year, 18-year-old Elizabeth Smith moved a jury to tears with the story of her hidden pregnancy and unassisted birth. The unmarried teen insisted her child was stillborn. In a daze, a few hours after giving birth, she carried the baby’s body to the rooftop of her tenement home and dropped it into the alley below.9.
After Elizabeth’s story broke, New York Daily News reporter Ruth Reynolds published an article listing several women whose circumstances had led them to infanticide. These gruesome tales sound more like works of horror than factual events, and I imagine it would be hard to invoke pity for most of the women mentioned. Here is a link if you’d like to view the original article.
Page 5 of 7
- “Pastor Gets Life for Poisoning Housemaid.” The Oshkosh Northwestern (Oshkosh, Wisconsin). 19 Aug 1938: Page 3
- “Pleads Guilty to Murder of Young Housemaid.” Caroll Daily Herald (Carroll, Iowa). 19 August 1938: Page 1
- Associated Press,”Youth Escapes Death Chair in Suicide Killing.” The Indianapolis News (Indianapolis, Indiana) 24 May 1938: Page 4
- “May Not be Punished for Child Murder.” Marshfield News-Herald (Marshfield, Wisconsin). 26 November 1935: Page 7
- “Blond Youth Sought by Police in Unwed Mother Case.” The Oshkosh Northwestern (Oshkosh, Wisconsin) 18 Aug 1936: Page 3
- Associated Press,”Unwed Mother Confesses to Drowning of Three Infants.” Green Bay Press-Gazette (Green Bay, Wisconsin) 02 Apr 1943: Page 2
- “Unwed Mother of Dead Baby Sent to Hospital.” Wisconson State Journal (Milwaukee, Wisconsin) 21 April 1936: Page 20
- “Unwed Slayer of Babe, Freed, Begins New Life.” Daily News (New York, New York) 01 Nov 1936: Page 48